Ask the Expert
www.canfp.org
Ask a Question | CANFP Store | Annual Conference | Home 

Ask the Expert 
 
 A Man's Perspective
 
 Achieving Pregnancy
 
 Contraception
 
 Could I Be Pregnant?
 
 Dating Conception
 
 Marital Sexuality
 
 Miscellaneous
 
 Monitors
 
 NFP
 
 PMS
 
 PMS / Mood Swings
 
 Questions About My Cycle
 
 Teens Ask
 
 Women's Health
Search

Marital Sexuality Last Updated: Feb 2nd, 2010 - 23:12:01


Love in Sickness and in Health
Answered by: Fr. Toschi
Feb 1, 2010, 14:36

Email this article
  Printer friendly page

Question

I was happy to see the quality of the responses from the experts on your site, but I did not see any that dealt with my situation. If I missed something, please feel free to merely point me in the right direction.

My wife and I are lifelong Catholics who have been married for over twenty years. Due to some medical issues on her part, we have not had any sexual contact for several years. Things are improving to the point where we are considering some restarting of our physical relationship, but actual penetration will still not be possible.

Since the lack of intercourse in this situation is not under our control as a couple, does the church still rule out all forms of sexual contact (in particular, "mutual manual stimulation")?

PS: If you feel that this is an issue that is more appropriately addressed to our individual confessors, just let me know, and I won't look for a public response.

Answer

To live for years without sexual contact is certainly a great sacrifice, and also a great expression of your vocation to love each other "in sickness" as well as in health. Hopefully God has enriched and deepened your love in ways that perhaps would not have occurred had there not been this illness.

In the absence of the possibility of intercourse, couples should certainly continue to express affection in physical ways that do not lead to climax or become an occasion for the sin of masturbation, either alone or together. If penetration becomes even somewhat possible, then manual stimulation in the hope of achieving intercourse would certainly be admissible. This would be different from stimulation that had not even a possibility of achieving its God-given purpose.

Certainly I would be happy to discuss this with you more personally by telephone, should you need further clarification.

In Christ,
Fr. Larry Toschi, O.S.J.


Fr. Larry Toschi

Fr. Larry Toschi, OSJ, is Pastor of St. Joachims in Madera, CA which hosts an active parish based NFP program, and a member of the Advisory Board of CANFP.


© Copyright 2005 by CANFP

The information on this page and web site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical diagnosis and treatment by a physician.

Top of Page

Marital Sexuality
Latest Headlines
Both Spiritual and Physical Health Needed
Love in Sickness and in Health
Definition and Intention of Marriage
Husband Insists on Vasectomy
Rules of Engagement
Gift of Self
Second Thoughts About Avoiding Pregnancy
Striving for Balance
Doctor Advises "No More Pregnancies"
What Makes a Valid Marriage?